‘The Traitors’ Season 4: Who Went Home on Episodes 4 & 5?

Can they catch a traitor? Episodes four and five of The Traitors were anything but boring. Four more people went home — two were “murdered,” and two were banished. Find out who remained and who left on Season 4.

Hosted by Alan Cumming, The Peacock show has a group of people, with some of them being Faithfuls and some of them being Traitors. IF the Faithfuls find the Traitors before the end of the game, they split the prize pot of $250,000. However, if there are any traitors left by the finale, they take home all of the money.

The 23 competitors this season are Donna Kelce, Porsha Williams (The Real Housewives of Atlanta), Caroline Stanbury (The Real Housewives of Dubai), Candiace Dillard Bassett (The Real Housewives of Potomac), Lisa Rinna (The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills), Dorinda Medley (The Real Housewives of New York), Ian Terry (Big Brother), Tiffany Mitchell (Big Brother), Rob Cesternino (Survivor), Natalie Anderson (Survivor), and Yamil “Yam Yam” Arocho (Survivor), Rob Rausch (Love Island USA), Maura Higgins (Love Island USA), Colton Underwood (The Bachelor), Kristen Kish (Top Chef), Eric Nam, Mark Ballas (Dancing With the Stars), Monét X Change (RuPaul’s Drag Race), Stephen Colletti (Laguna Beach), Michael Rapaport, Johnny Weir, Ron Funches, and Tara Lipinski.

Read on to find out who left in episodes four and five. Tune in next week for episode six.

Who are the traitors?

A twist this season was that the first traitor would be picked in front of everyone. The competitors had to stand in front of Cumming as he opened up a trunk. If it was empty, they were safe. If it had the traitor card in it, they became the first traitor. However, they weren’t revealed right away.

The other traitors picked at the round table were Candiace Dillard Bassett, Lisa Rinna, and Rob Rausch.

The fourth traitor remained a secret and did not meet the other traitors. They had the full say in who gets murdered and produced a short-list of people eligible for murder for the other traitors to decide. Donna Kelce was revealed to be the Secret Traitor and was banished in episode two, so the twist ended.

Who was eliminated from The Traitors?

Episode 4

The contestants on the shortlist were tied to a tree in the forest and blindfolded. They could make their plea to the Traitors not murder them.

Murdered: Caroline Stanbury

Caroline looked the Traitors in the eyes and was shocked to find out that two Housewives murdered her.

“I’m sure I’ll see you after this,” she said to Rinna.

“You won’t,” the Traitor replied.

In the challenge, the contestants had to team up into groups. They had to find a spear in the woods next to a voodoo doll. Once they found the spear, they had to agree on who to put up for murder by putting the spear into the fire and then stabbing it into a huge dummy made of sticks. This went on until 10 people were chosen randomly for the next night’s murder. The team collected $20,000 for doing it successfully, bringing it up to $90,000.

Banished: Tiffany Mitchell (Faithful) with 15 votes (Ron received two, and Yam Yam received one)

Colton Underwood made a plea that she had been suspicious and was pulling too many people’s names out to be traitors. Eric Nam said that he heard a laugh while he was tied to a tree, and it sounded like Tiffany’s. In the end, Tiffany was banished.

Episode 5

Up for Murder: Ron, Tiffany (banished), Monet, Michael, Tara, Stephen, Lisa (Traitor), Maura, Johnny, Yam Yam

Murdered: Monét X Change

More from this section

Movies and TV shows casting across the US

In the next challenge, the contestants had to restore the Faithful Fountain to its original state. They did this by finding eight statues that went around the fountain after finding a coin in the fountain. Once they set them in the rightful places in the right amount of time, they would add money to their prize pot. They won $16,000, bringing it up to $106,000.

However, the catch was that there were shields hidden throughout. If those shields were taken, the people who took them would be safe from murder. If no one took a shield, then there would be no murder the next night. That result will not be revealed until episode six.

Banished: Michael Rappaport (Faithful) with 11 votes (Ron received five)

Rappaport had a big blowup at the round table and with Underwood before that, leading people to suspect he was a traitor.

Who has been previously eliminated?

Episode 1

Shortlist: Rob Rausch, Ian Terry, Mark Ballas, and Eric Nam

Murdered: No one

Banished: No one

Related

'The Traitors': Rob Cesternino Praises Cast’s 'Survivor' Records

Episode 2

Murdered: Ian Terry

Banished: Porsha Williams (Faithful) with 10 votes (Donna Kelce received 8, Michael Rappaport received 5)

Shortlist: Monét X Change, Rob Cesternino, Tara Lapinski, and Kristen Kish

Episode 3

Murdered: Rob Cesternino

Banished: Donna Kelce (secret traitor) with 19 votes (Michael and Yam Yam received one vote each)

Shortlist: Ron Funches, Caroline Stanbury, Eric Nam, and Kristen Kish

More Headlines:

• ‘The Traitors’ Season 4: Who Went Home on Episodes 4 & 5?
• ‘9-1-1’ Reveals What’s Wrong With Hen, Plus Jennifer Love Hewitt Talks Maddie vs. AI
• ‘Jeopardy!’ Fans React After Wildcard Finals ‘Nail-Biter’
• NBC’s Might Give ‘Mindhunter’ Fans a Consolation Prize for No Season 3 With This New Series Pilot
• ‘Percy Jackson’: Walker Scobell Interviews His Costars (VIDEO)