‘General Hospital’ First Look at Jonathan Bennett’s Debut — Why He’s Returning to Soaps Now

“Returning to daytime television was not on my bingo card for 2026,” admits Jonathan Bennett, who will make his General Hospital debut as Detective Joe Fitzpatrick on Monday, May 18.

For Bennett, who got his big break playing J.R. Chandler on All My Children in 2001, the opportunity was a full-circle moment he couldn’t pass up. “Daytime is where I learned to act,” he explains. “It’s where I learned what this business was. The opportunity to come back to where it all started just felt like the right thing to do. Plus, I was very excited to work with the best of the best, like [executive producer] Frank Valentini. He’s a legend.”

Disney/Christine Bartolucci

What sealed the deal was the role itself. “I feel like I hit the jackpot when this opportunity came because the character is something that I really wanted to play,” Bennett relays. “I’ve never read something where I was like, ‘I have to do it,’ and when I read this, I called my agent and said, ‘I’m playing this character.’”

Once Bennett arrived on set, he quickly remembered just how demanding daytime can be. “I’m not going to lie, I was completely nervous my first week,” he shares. “Not just because I was returning to the daytime world, but just the memorization and everything that comes along with that, I hadn’t done in so many years. Yes, I’ve shot hundreds of other projects, but there’s nothing like stepping back in this world that’s very specific and having to relearn all the logistics. I had to retrain my brain.”

Related

'General Hospital' Stars Reveal Dream Gio & Emma Storyline

Any nerves faded thanks to the positive atmosphere behind the scenes. “Everyone just made me feel so welcome that it took all the pressure off,” he relays. “The cast and the directors and producers and Frank are absolutely incredible, and they’re just so supportive and loving, and I immediately felt it from the moment I walked in the first day. I felt like I’ve been here for 20 years; I just felt so comfortable.’”

Having a familiar face nearby also made the transition easier. “My favorite in the whole world, Cameron Mathison [Drew Cain], and I were on All My Children together,” he says. “So, Cameron was actually the first call I made when this opportunity came up. I was like, ‘Cameron, should I do this? I really want to do this.’ He said, ‘You should do this. It’s going to be very fun for you, and you’re going to enjoy it.’ There’s something about being around Cameron, you feel so safe. He has this magical energy, ever since I met him when I was 19 years old, had just fallen off the turnip truck from Ohio, and moved to New York City to make it big. Back then, Cameron was a safe space for me to be around, and here in Port Charles, nothing has changed. He’s the same guy.”

Paul Archuleta/Getty Images

Bennett is also eager to reconnect with another familiar face from his AMC days: Michael E. Knight (ex-Tad Martin), who now plays GH‘s Martin Gray. “I can’t wait; I hope he remembers me,” Bennett adds.

Looking back, Bennett still considers his time in Pine Valley one of the defining experiences of his life. “Being on All My Children was the most fun,” he raves. “It’s seriously one of my core memories and highlights of my life that I’ll never forget. Instead of paying to go to college to learn how to act, I got paid to go to set to learn how to act. I literally was learning how to be an actor in real time in front of the whole world on that show, and It’s a memory I’ll always have.”

More from this section

Movies and TV shows casting across the US

Disney/Christine Bartolucci

That early soap training soon paved the way for another career-defining role: Aaron Samuels in the 2004 blockbuster Mean Girls. At the time, Bennett had no idea the movie was destined to become a phenomenon. “We were filming a movie in Canada with Tina Fey and a bunch of people from SNL, and that’s all we thought it was,” he recalls. “We didn’t realize it was going to become what it was going to become. It wasn’t until we saw the first screening of it at Paramount. I remember watching it, and when that screening was over, we all kind of looked at each other, and I looked at one of my cast members, and I said, ‘Either this is the worst movie we’ve ever made, or it’s going to be the best movie that we’ve ever made.’”

Bennett credits the film with changing everything for him professionally. “Mean Girls is the reason I’m back on General Hospital,” he points out. “It made the cast part of pop culture, and I acknowledge that the only reason I get to have so many jobs is because Mean Girls put our faces and those characters as part of millennial pop culture that people adored. And so that opened up a lot of doors that probably wouldn’t have been open had I not done it.”

Paramount/courtesy Everett Collection

One of those doors led to a successful run of Hallmark Channel films, including projects Bennett says have become especially meaningful to him. “What I love about Hallmark Channel is that ever since I did The Christmas House in 2020, where I had the first same-sex kiss on the network, the reaction was so positive,” he says. “I got messages like, ‘You don’t understand what it’s like to see a love that looks like mine in a Hallmark movie.’ And that’s when I knew my mission was to tell LGBTQ stories for a broad audience, to normalize LGBTQ love by telling stories of love that look like everyone else’s. When you do that, you’re able to change hearts and minds and help open those doors for people to understand.”

Disney/Christine Bartolucci

Beyond acting, Bennett has also built a thriving hosting career spanning Hallmark Channel, Food Network, and live events, like the Times Square New Year’s Eve ball drop. “I just love making people smile, and that’s why I love hosting TV shows,” he offers. “I host all the wars on Food Network — Halloween Wars, Cake Wars, Cupcake Wars. Fifteen years ago, I started hosting shows on Food Network, and it’s been so much fun. I’ve gained and lost over 1000 pounds over the course of 15 years, and all those cakes, but it’s worth it. It’s like I’ve hit the trifecta with the fans; I find there’s a lot of overlap. If you watch Food Network, you probably watch Hallmark Channel, and if you watch Hallmark Channel, you probably watch General Hospital.”

The response to his casting, Bennett notes, reaffirmed that returning to daytime was the right move. “The outpouring of love from just the announcement made me really emotional,” he says. “I was driving home, talking to my husband, and I started having tears roll down my face. It just feels so good to go somewhere where you’re so loved and you feel so supported before you even start. It felt like a weight was taken off my shoulders. I just was like, ‘Oh, this is exactly where I’m supposed to be.’”

General Hospital, Weekdays, ABC, Check Local Listings

More Headlines:

• Is TV’s Next Hot Thing Brewing on TikTok’s 2026 Discover List?
• ‘General Hospital’ First Look at Jonathan Bennett’s Debut — Why He’s Returning to Soaps Now
• How ‘The Vampire Lestat’ Maintains ‘Interview With the Vampire’s Gothic Drama
• ESPN’s Mina Kimes Shares Wagering Strategy After Big ‘Celebrity Jeopardy!’ Win
• HGTV’s Jasmine Roth Shares Major Family News After New Show Announcement