Alton Selectboard

Alton Selectboard Vice Chair Drew Carter submitted a resignation letter on May 14, and rescinded it before it was approved by the selectboard, after discovering he was prohibited from taking a town position due to a conflict of interest ordinance. Pictured, from left, are Town Administrator Ryan Heath, Chair Paul LaRochelle, Carter, and selectboard members Andrew Morse, Richard Shea and Jack Sleeper, at the May 5 special Town Meeting deliberative session. (Bob Martin/The Laconia Daily Sun file photo)

ALTON — A selectboard member submitted a letter of resignation in May, in order to accept the town’s code official and building inspector position. That letter was quickly rescinded, after the board learned of an ordinance prohibiting him from doing so.

This raised alarm for one property owner.

Chris Niland, a resident of Rumney who owns property in Alton, sent the May 14 resignation letter, signed by Vice Chair Drew Carter, to The Laconia Daily Sun.

Town Administrator Ryan Heath said Niland obtained the letter through a public records request. Both he and Chair Paul LaRochelle said it wasn't an issue.

“It was a conditional resignation based on being considered for a full-time code enforcement building inspector position,” Heath said.

“No harm, no malice,” LaRochelle added.

Heath said Carter was offered the job, and was going to accept, but town leaders found an ordinance addressing conflicts of interest.

“We didn’t realize beforehand that the town had adopted an amendment to the conflict of interest ordinance, stating that an elected official can’t assume full-time employment until two years after serving,” Heath said.

Heath said the board had to rescind any consideration for the position, as did Carter.

“He rescinded before the board ever saw it or was able to act on it,” Heath said.

Heath said Niland believed the resignation was automatically effective, as he wrote in an email to Alton Selectboard. Heath said that could be true if it was out of spite or anger, but that wasn’t the case. He said it is the town’s position that he had “every right to rescind.”

The ordinance amendment was accepted in 2009, according to Heath, before any sitting selectboard member was in office, and before Heath's tenure. Heath was previously the chief of the Alton Police Department.

The letter was sent May 14, and Carter was “excused” from the next meeting, on May 26, according to the minutes. Heath said Carter sat out the discussion about the ordinance, during a non-public portion of the meeting.

“He would have had to recuse himself,” Heath said. “He didn’t sit out because he was resigning. He knew they needed to discuss matters that concerned him.”

Heath consulted with the town’s legal counsel, who informed him the appropriate steps were taken.

The selectboard then moved on to consider other applicants. The position has since been filled by Richard Therrien, the former building inspector for New Durham.

Resignation letter

“It is with mixed emotions that I offer this letter of resignation from my position on the Alton Selectboard,” Carter wrote in an email addressed to LaRochelle.

Carter wrote he enjoyed his time serving, and was honored Alton residents trusted him in the position. He was “saddened” he had to resign.

“I am also looking forward to my new position as Code Enforcement Officer and helping the community from a different perspective,” Carter wrote.

Carter expressed his “gratitude and respect” to the board members, and said they have all had the best interests of residents and visitors in mind. He added that after three default budgets it was a difficult period.

“I wish the board the best in the future and trust that the transition spurred by my resignation will go smoothly and the harmony of the operations of the Board continue,” Carter wrote. “If there is anything that I can do to assist the board, either in this transition or in any future matter, please do not hesitate to reach out to me.”

Carter, a former building inspector in Strafford, said on Tuesday he had gone through the entire interview process, and provided the letter of resignation on the condition of getting the job offer.

Shortly after it was sent, Heath called and told him about the regulation, which had seemingly been omitted from an employee handbook. He said a former selectboard member notified Heath about it, and he took back the resignation immediately.

While it was tough not to be able to take the job, the silver lining was he could stay on the board. He also said that Therrien, who became available, is "a good grab and a great candidate," and he voted for him to take the job.

Taxpayer concern

Niland emailed the selectboard on Oct. 27, with “Andrew Carter Resignation” in the subject line. The message was addressed to “remaining members” and included the names “Paul l, Jack s, Richard s, Mr Morse.”

The email called for a “cease and desist,” and referenced Carter’s access to private records, and making decisions and votes in town matters. Niland's message also called for him to be removed from all boards and committees “at once.”

“According to state law and common sense Andrew Carter's resignation was effective immediately on submitting whether verbal or documentation,” Niland’s email stated. “I find he has met both these burdens.”

He said the board has “refused to act” and that “court intervention is absolutely a possibility.” Niland asked they “not make matters worse” by “having to erase the damage done over the last six months."

“I was on it from the start in May..it was in legal minutes..period,” Niland wrote. “I don't like the alternatives either .but there is no choice .you must act immediately and place another selectman in at once .I suppose that's Brock..”

Brock Mitchell unsuccessfully ran for selectboard in 2026, when Jack Sleeper was elected, and Richard Shea retained his seat.

Niland included a photograph of a complaint he filed with the town on Oct. 27. It states Carter resigned on May 14, and it was effective immediately on May 14, and RSA 669:63 applies.

RSA 669:63 refers to the filling of vacancies and reads as follows: “Vacancies in the board of selectmen shall be filled by appointment made by the remaining selectmen. Whenever the selectmen fail to make such appointment, the superior court or any justice thereof, on petition of any citizen of the town, and after such notice as the court shall deem reasonable, may appoint a suitable person to fill the vacancy; provided, however, that if the town has adopted the provisions of RSA 669:61, IV, and a petition thereunder is submitted before the submission of a petition under this section, the provisions of RSA 669:61, IV shall apply.”

RSA 669:61 refers to vacancies in town offices, and “IV” states the “legislative body of a town may adopt or rescind the optional procedure in this paragraph for filling vacancies in elective town offices.”

The read the entire state statute, visit gc.nh.gov/rsa/html/LXIII/669/669-61.htm.

Ongoing dispute

“As usual it sounds like Mr. Niland is giving you only part of the story he feels is newsworthy,” Heath wrote in an email about Carter’s resignation. “He did not provide you with the meeting minutes we sent him as well explaining the situation.”

Heath said there was nothing nefarious or anything to hide about the situation. He said it's a case where Niland was coming after Alton town leaders out of spite.

Heath was recently cited for disorderly conduct violations after allegedly blocking the walking path of Niland outside Town Hall on June 3. He was first charged with obstructing his path on a sidewalk, and a second charge was added on Nov. 6, for allegedly obstructing Niland's walking path on Depot Street. Heath has pleaded not guilty to both charges.

Heath said there has been ongoing strain for years between the town and Niland, stemming from a property rights issue. Since then, he said Niland has taken to the internet to attack him and other members of town government.

He also said Niland has made town employees uncomfortable, and alleged he was seen taking photographs of their cars on more than one occasion.

Niland did not respond to questions about Heath's claims.

Heath is represented by attorney James Rosenberg of Shaheen & Gordon PA, and entered a plea of not guilty on on Aug. 17. His team filed a motion to dismiss the charges. The state objected.

Heath has denied any wrongdoing, and is due in Laconia District Court for a Dec. 9 trial date.

Heath said in a previous interview he is considering taking legal action against Niland.

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.