By THOMAS P. CALDWELL, LACONIA DAILY SUN
Many local officials whose towns have been fighting the Northern Pass hydroelectric project were taken by surprise yesterday by Massachusetts’ decision to terminate its energy purchase agreement with Eversource.
“That’s good news for us,” said Bristol Town Administrator Nik Coates.
Rep. Steve Rand, D-Plymouth, agreed.
“That’s very exciting news, of course, to those of us who’ve been trying to get out from under the great Eversource rock,” he said.
Eversource reacted to yesterday’s news by vowing to “pursue all options” to complete the 192-mile transmission line.
Both the company and Franklin’s acting city manager said the decision came as no surprise, given the status of the permitting process. The state’s Site Evaluation Committee, which rules on such projects, had denied Eversource’s permit in February and, on March 12, announced it would suspend its oral decision on the company’s appeal, pending the issuance of a written order at a later date.
“Clearly, we’re disappointed with that decision,” said City Manager Judy Milner, “but we understand where Massachusetts stands as a result of the SEC decision and the delay in making a decision on an appeal.
“We think it’s a project that’s worthwhile and would make some money for municipalities, not just Franklin. In our area, we need energy, so this project is very vital to this region.”
The Northern Pass transmission line would carry 1,090 megawatts of direct-current energy from the Canadian border to Franklin, where a substation would convert the power to alternating current. From there the electricity would go to another substation in Deerfield, and then into the New England power grid.
Most of the project would run over existing rights of way, but some of the narrower corridors would require higher towers, which has raised concerns among residents of the affected towns. Eversource agreed to bury some portions of the line to alleviate those concerns, but even that proved to be controversial in Plymouth, where laying the cable would disrupt the downtown area during the construction phase.
“The whole tearing up of Main Street was really something,” Rand commented. “It’s been a long battle for those of us in the North Country, and I think we are feeling pretty good about it right now. It’s the second shoe to drop. There may be some celebrating tonight.”
Still, he said, “We’re always cautiously optimistic. These battles are often fought in courts of law, based on the civil rights of corporations and their personhood in the courts. It’s never easy to tell what is actually going to happen, but this is a very good sign.”
Company response
In a statement, the company said, “Eversource and Hydro-Québec remain committed to the success of the project. No other project has obtained the necessary approvals from federal permitting authorities in the U.S. and Canada, and secured agreements with major contractors and the IBEW. It is because of these achievements that Northern Pass was originally selected as the top bid in the Massachusetts Clean Energy solicitation.”
Coates said, “All along, the position of the Bristol selectmen has been trying to protect the interests of the neighborhood and the town. If they came back with a realistic plan to bury the lines, we’d be willing to talk, but they weren’t interested in meeting us halfway. That’s why the SEC based their decision on the impact to the towns’ orderly development. That’s pretty telling. The company didn’t seem very willing to work with us to understand our concerns.”
Eversource spokesman Martin Murray said the company had established the $200 million Forward NH Fund to address the potential for impacts on property values, to promote tourism, and to boost economic development, as well as dedicating $100 million of that fund for further conditions that the Site Evaluation Committee might require.
“Best of luck to them,” said Coates. “Putting $100 million into a fund was only an attempt to bribe the towns. It didn’t work.”
Plymouth had passed a rights-based ordinance as part of its strategy in opposing Northern Pass. Rand said it may have had some impact, but, more likely, the amount of opposition was having a cumulative effect.
“The RBO was kind of like a seal of authenticity on the seriousness of the community,” Rand said. “Did it change their minds, or did it kick it over? I don’t know. Was it part of the reason why they decided that harm was out there, that the towns were willing to stick their necks out enough to fight it without constitutional authority to do so? I don’t know if the SEC committee was reading about our battles or not. I suspect they were aware of it, and I suspect it was one more thing in the quiver.”
With Northern Pass stalled in New Hampshire, the Massachusetts Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs announced that the state now would be working toward a new agreement with New England Clean Energy Connect, a hydropower project proposed by Central Maine Power Company.
Murray said Eversource is continuing to focus on earning the New Hampshire permit.
“We will work first at the Site Evaluation Committee to seek reconsideration of its decision and, if necessary, consider an appeal to the New Hampshire Supreme Court,” he said.
“With the continued retirement of existing power plants, the high dependence on natural gas, and the keen desire to establish new sources of clean energy, we expect there will be additional buyers for the energy to be delivered on the Northern Pass line,” he said.
“Presuming we earned our state permit in the first half of this year, Northern Pass had an in-service date of late 2020. The project in Maine hopes to be online in 2022. I can’t speak for that project’s chances to meet that timetable.”


(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.