At Saturday’s Town Meeting in the Winnisquam Regional High School, residents showed town leaders they were serious about change when, earlier in the week, they dumped two incumbent selectmen and picked three new members for the board.

In an unusual move — and one that may not prove to be legally permissible, according to the town’s attorney — voters choose to rescind the action they took at last year’s meeting when they then voted to appropriate nearly $1-million to build a new police station at 61 Business Park Drive.

Saturday's 103-3 vote, which represented only about 4-percent of Tilton’s total number of 2,649 registered voters, was actually taken on an amended version of a petitioned article submitted by Pat Clark, Scott Davis and 125 other citizens. The original article asked the meeting only to vote on a proposal to “open discussion and get clarification on what was presented and passed” at last year’s Town Meeting.

Moderator Ken Randall had only read the original motion when Selectboard Chairman Katherine Dawson rose and read a letter from Town Counsel Walter Mitchell advising residents that they could not “take back” the authorization they gave the selectmen last year to sell bonds for the building project. “The problem is the bonds have already been issued (i.e., sold),” she said. “It cannot be legally be rescinded… No valid action can be taken on this.”

But Clark read a different legal opinion from attorney Daniel Crean, which he said the petitioners personally paid to receive. In part, it read that the N.H. Supreme Court had showed in decisions over the years to be “most liberal” in allowing municipalities to interpret or change warrant articles at their meetings. And it also noted that the example noted in Mitchell’s letter concerned an SB-2 town, which has no relationship to Tilton’s traditional Town Meeting situation.

“You can’t rescind the bonding authority once it’s already been bonded,” Dawson insisted. “It’s been done.”

“I’ve got more information in my briefcase that says the voters do have the authority to rescind bonding,” Clark said. He said he thought the town should vote on the matter and move ahead with the outcome if it was legal — and deal with the ramifications if it proved not to be.”

Moderator Randall agreed with Clark and allowed the article to be amended to include the proposal of rescinding the action of the town last year to raise and appropriate $910,000 “representing a partial amount of the unexpanded portion of the funds raised and appropriated” last year “for the purpose of (building) a Tilton Police Station and Emergency Operations Center.”

The article goes on to outline the formation of a new seven-person committee to “investigate the best location for a Life Safety Building with consideration being given to the 61 Business Park Drive site, the sites coming out of the 2006 Police Department Study Committee, and any other potential locations and to consider the best sue or disposition of any property acquired” as a result of last year’s warrant article being passed. (The article also requires the group use the 2008 Municipal Resource Report of the level of service the town gets from the Tilton-Northfield Fire Department, the 2008 Police Department study and feedback from the Fire Department’s district staff.)

The committee, which is to be appointed by Randall, will consider of one representative of the Police Department, one from the Selectboard, one from the Fire Department, and four members of the public. The group will choose a chairman from the public members and issue a final report before the 2010 Town Meeting.

“This committee shall supersede any other committees that have been created for related purposes and those committees are hereby dissolved,” the article concludes. The committee will try to “determine the best site for a Life Safety b=Building with the idea that a Police Department facility may be designed and built there initially, with the potential of adding a Fire Department facility at a later date; develop conceptual plans and cost estimates; (and) investigate the need to include an Emergency Operations Center within the Police Department facility.” And Town Hall staff will help the group look for outside funding sources, such as grants and donations.

In a short video presentation, Clark asked for the opinion of “another expert,” and echoed the Paul Newman character from the 60s film “Cool Hand Luke”, who said,” What we’ve got here is failure to communicate.”

Then using clips from Selectboard meetings, Clark indicated that the board had ignored some common sense rules like, “Don’t make promises you can’t keep” and “Be truthful.” He showed how the board members discussed low-balling the estimated cost of the police station building in the hopes that building bids would come in low. At a recording of a meeting held on Feb. 14, 2008, Tom Cavanaugh indicated that there was $100,000 in a “contingency fund” that could be used to cover the cost of any building cost overruns.

Clarks said the idea “kept the townspeople in the dark” about what the board thought the real costs of the stationhouse would be.

At the same meeting, another selectman pointed out that most people probably thought of the “operations center” as a local one but the state was recommending it be a regional operation, such as ones proposed for Plymouth and Littleton.”

Most importantly, the original building estimate of $1-million came in at the end of the bidding process at about $2.2-million, Clark said.

He added that he did not mean to imply that the Selectboard had purposely acted dishonestly. “These are hardworking selectmen who put in a lot of time but we missed the boat on this one,” he said. The best idea now was to “hold back the money and come back next year and hopefully spend it more wisely.”

His comments were met with applause.

None of the selectmen spoke against or voted on the amended article, which was accepted in place of the original one, 108-1.

In other action, the residents voted to accept the proposed annual operating budget of $5.2-million, 95-0, an increase of about $500,000 of last year’s approved figure of $4.7-million.

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.