Cuts totaled $745k & commissioners have legal opinion on the way
Written by Roger Amsden
LACONIA — Belknap County Commissioners are seeking an opinion from an outside legal expert on whether or not the Belknap County Convention's Monday night move to strip it of its authority over executing the county budget is consistent with state law.
Commission Chairman John Thomas (R-Belmont) said yesterday that the commission hopes to have the opinion by the end of the week as it attempts to mount a challenge to the convention's move, which comes in the midst of attempt by the local House members to assert line item authority over the budget and to prevent the commissioners from exercising any discretion in transferring funds from one account to another.
''The commission runs the county and taking away that authority keeps us from doing that job,'' said Thomas, who said that he has tried for years to get the Legislature to clarify exactly what the law (RSA 24:14) which was cited by the delegation as giving it authority over the budget, actually means.
''We need clarity on this. Different counties do it differently and there needs to be a clear understanding of who has authority over the budget,'' said Thomas.
The County Convention voted 10-8 Monday night in support of a motion by Rep. Richard Burchell (R-Gilmanton) to take the budget transfer authority away from the commission. It then proceeded to vote on a number of subcommittee recommendations for cuts to specific line items in department budgets, and in the case of one subcommittee, for recommended changes which would affect all departments of county government.
Rep. Herb Vadney (R-Meredith), who chaired one of the subcommittees, offered the motion to strike funds for a proposed three-percent step raise from the budget, along with funding for sick day and longevity bonuses. He also proposed requiring employees to pay the entire 7.3-percent increase in health insurance premiums.
The motion to deny the pay raise was adopted on a straight party-line vote, with all 13 Republicans supporting it and all five Democrats opposed. Dennis Fields (R-Sanbornton) joined the Democrats to oppose passing along the increase in health insurance premiums but it was supported 12-6.
All told, the provisional cuts made Monday night added up to $745,000. according to County Administrator Debra Shackett, who said that the County Convention is scheduled to meet again on February 4 at 5 p.m. for a continuation of budget discussions.
That is more than a half million less than the $1.3 million that Convention Chairman Colette Worsman (R-Meredith) has set as a target for cuts from the $26.8 million spending plan proposed by the commissioners.
Thomas said that from his perspective as a former member and chairman of the County Convention, Monday's meeting was very confusing for members of the public, who had to wait three hours before what was billed as a public hearing on the budget was opened.
''It was very confusing. Many people weren't sure what budget was being talked about,'' said Thomas.
Peter Ellis of Gilford, chairman of the advisory board for the Belknap County Cooperative Extension Service, one of the outside agencies partially funded by the county, said that he was disappointed in the way the meeting was run.
''I commend them for trying to cut the budget. But they should be looking at the bottom line and not trying to micromanage the budget.'' said Ellis.
He said that there appeared to be no rules of parliamentary procedure being followed at the meeting and that motions were being discussed without being seconded and that there were motions which were seconded for which no votes were taken,
''It was very chaotic. And the public wasn't allowed to speak until after all the votes were taken. There was nothing left for them to say on particular items they supported. The only people who spoke who were those who supported the cuts,'' said Ellis.
He said that he hopes that when the convention meets next the public will be allowed to participate and that it will have a clear idea of exactly what is taking place.
Commission Chairman John Thomas (R-Belmont) said yesterday that the commission hopes to have the opinion by the end of the week as it attempts to mount a challenge to the convention's move, which comes in the midst of attempt by the local House members to assert line item authority over the budget and to prevent the commissioners from exercising any discretion in transferring funds from one account to another.
''The commission runs the county and taking away that authority keeps us from doing that job,'' said Thomas, who said that he has tried for years to get the Legislature to clarify exactly what the law (RSA 24:14) which was cited by the delegation as giving it authority over the budget, actually means.
''We need clarity on this. Different counties do it differently and there needs to be a clear understanding of who has authority over the budget,'' said Thomas.
The County Convention voted 10-8 Monday night in support of a motion by Rep. Richard Burchell (R-Gilmanton) to take the budget transfer authority away from the commission. It then proceeded to vote on a number of subcommittee recommendations for cuts to specific line items in department budgets, and in the case of one subcommittee, for recommended changes which would affect all departments of county government.
Rep. Herb Vadney (R-Meredith), who chaired one of the subcommittees, offered the motion to strike funds for a proposed three-percent step raise from the budget, along with funding for sick day and longevity bonuses. He also proposed requiring employees to pay the entire 7.3-percent increase in health insurance premiums.
The motion to deny the pay raise was adopted on a straight party-line vote, with all 13 Republicans supporting it and all five Democrats opposed. Dennis Fields (R-Sanbornton) joined the Democrats to oppose passing along the increase in health insurance premiums but it was supported 12-6.
All told, the provisional cuts made Monday night added up to $745,000. according to County Administrator Debra Shackett, who said that the County Convention is scheduled to meet again on February 4 at 5 p.m. for a continuation of budget discussions.
That is more than a half million less than the $1.3 million that Convention Chairman Colette Worsman (R-Meredith) has set as a target for cuts from the $26.8 million spending plan proposed by the commissioners.
Thomas said that from his perspective as a former member and chairman of the County Convention, Monday's meeting was very confusing for members of the public, who had to wait three hours before what was billed as a public hearing on the budget was opened.
''It was very confusing. Many people weren't sure what budget was being talked about,'' said Thomas.
Peter Ellis of Gilford, chairman of the advisory board for the Belknap County Cooperative Extension Service, one of the outside agencies partially funded by the county, said that he was disappointed in the way the meeting was run.
''I commend them for trying to cut the budget. But they should be looking at the bottom line and not trying to micromanage the budget.'' said Ellis.
He said that there appeared to be no rules of parliamentary procedure being followed at the meeting and that motions were being discussed without being seconded and that there were motions which were seconded for which no votes were taken,
''It was very chaotic. And the public wasn't allowed to speak until after all the votes were taken. There was nothing left for them to say on particular items they supported. The only people who spoke who were those who supported the cuts,'' said Ellis.
He said that he hopes that when the convention meets next the public will be allowed to participate and that it will have a clear idea of exactly what is taking place.
Last Updated on Wednesday, 23 January 2013 19:55
Hits: 292
I-L board finds ObamaCare will take additional $90k bite out of taxpayers, just to cover support staff
Written by Adam Drapcho
CENTER HARBOR — The Inter-Lakes School Board has reached an agreement with the Inter-Lakes Support Staff Association that will give each member a raise of 70 cents per hour. Additionally, the agreement adds a new health insurance plan that is expected to cost taxpayers an additional $91,148 next school year.
School board member Howard Cunningham, who headed the negotiating team for the district, reported the status of the collective bargaining agreement after the conclusion of a board meeting held on Tuesday night in Center Harbor. He said the agreement, which has been ratified by both the school board and the union, will be in effect for one school year if approved by voters at the annual district meeting in March.
At the meeting, board members unanimously agreed to ask voters at the district meeting to approve of an operating budget of $20,998,543 for the 2013-2014 school year. The proposal represents an increase of 2.74 percent over the current budget. More than half of the increase in the budget is due to increased share of teacher retirement costs passed from the state level to local districts.
The proposed operating budget does not include increases that would result from the adoption of the new support staff contract.
Cunningham said the negotiated wage increase will combine with a 20 cent-per-hour raise that employees will receive as a regular "step" increase, bringing the total raise each support staff employee will see to 90 cents per hour. He was uncertain what effect the raises would have on the overall budget, though he added that the increase brings Inter-Lakes up to the average level of compensation for support staff when compared to nearby districts.
The new health care plan, he said, was one Matthew Thornton (Anthem) enacted "as a step to next year," when the national Affordable Health Care Act will require districts to offer a plan that would cost employees no more than 9.5 percent of the lowest-paid employee's salary. The new plan doesn't quite reach that level, he said, as the district desired to avoid making the jump in one budget cycle. If the district were to fail to comply with the requirements by the time the legislation goes into effect, he said, there would be heavy fines to pay.
The Inter-Lakes School Board has scheduled a public hearing on the budget proposal on Wednesday, February 6. The hearing will begin at 6:30 p.m. and will be held at the Inter-Lakes Community Auditorium.
School board member Howard Cunningham, who headed the negotiating team for the district, reported the status of the collective bargaining agreement after the conclusion of a board meeting held on Tuesday night in Center Harbor. He said the agreement, which has been ratified by both the school board and the union, will be in effect for one school year if approved by voters at the annual district meeting in March.
At the meeting, board members unanimously agreed to ask voters at the district meeting to approve of an operating budget of $20,998,543 for the 2013-2014 school year. The proposal represents an increase of 2.74 percent over the current budget. More than half of the increase in the budget is due to increased share of teacher retirement costs passed from the state level to local districts.
The proposed operating budget does not include increases that would result from the adoption of the new support staff contract.
Cunningham said the negotiated wage increase will combine with a 20 cent-per-hour raise that employees will receive as a regular "step" increase, bringing the total raise each support staff employee will see to 90 cents per hour. He was uncertain what effect the raises would have on the overall budget, though he added that the increase brings Inter-Lakes up to the average level of compensation for support staff when compared to nearby districts.
The new health care plan, he said, was one Matthew Thornton (Anthem) enacted "as a step to next year," when the national Affordable Health Care Act will require districts to offer a plan that would cost employees no more than 9.5 percent of the lowest-paid employee's salary. The new plan doesn't quite reach that level, he said, as the district desired to avoid making the jump in one budget cycle. If the district were to fail to comply with the requirements by the time the legislation goes into effect, he said, there would be heavy fines to pay.
The Inter-Lakes School Board has scheduled a public hearing on the budget proposal on Wednesday, February 6. The hearing will begin at 6:30 p.m. and will be held at the Inter-Lakes Community Auditorium.
Last Updated on Thursday, 07 February 2013 01:55
Hits: 814
Revolution: Belknap Convention majority strips commisioners of budget transfer authority & goes after wages & benefits
Written by Michael Kitch
LACONIA — The Belknap County Convention, voting largely along party lines, last night tied the hands of the Belknap County Commission while denying a pay raise and trimming the benefits of county employees — all much to the delight of all but a handful of some 75 of their constituents at a public hearing on the 2013 county budget.
Although the convention approved the recommendations of its sub-committees to reduce a number of expenditures, the size of the dent in the $26.8-million budget proposed by the commissioners remains to be calculated. Rep. Colette Worsman (R-Meredith), who chairs the convention, said that she aimed to cut $1.3-million from the budget, which would entirely offset the 8.9-percent increase in the county tax burden projected by the commissioners.
Shortly after Worsman opened the meeting, Rep. Richard Burchell (R-Gilmanton) proposed stripping the commission of much of its authority over the budget, in particular it power to transfer funds from line-to-line within the plan. Reading from a prepared statement, the freshman lawmaker, said that "the power of the purse belongs to you — the convention. The enumerated powers of commissions are very limited," he continued, charging that the commissioners "attempt to assign to themselves the powers granted to you."
Burchell cited state law (RSA 24:14) which reads "unless otherwise ordered by the county convention ... whenever it appears that the amount appropriated for a specific purpose will not be used in whole or in part for such purpose, the county commissioners may use such sum to augment other appropriations, if necessary, provided the total payments for all purposes do not exceed the total sum of appropriations in any year made by the county convention." The law, he insisted, is clear and the convention would be derelict in its duty to grant the commission discretion to transfer funds.
"The commission is not accountable" he declared, urging the convention "not to hide behind the veil of executive discretion."
For some years the commission has enjoyed authority to transfer funds, only seeking the approval of the executive committee for amounts of more than $10,000. Moreover, the convention's authority over the budget has been limited to the bottom-line, much as in towns where the budget committee and town meeting approve the total spending package while the board of selectmen retain the power to transfer funds between departments and line-items.
Rep. David Huot (D-Laconia) cautioned that by taking away the authority of the commission, the convention would make a lot of work for its executive committee, which could find itself managing the budget day-by-day.
Rep. Dennis Fields (R-Sanbornton) said he would votes against the motion because "I don't know what the legal ramifications are."
In fact, the delineation of budgetary authority between the convention and the commission is neither straightforward nor settled and according to Betsy Miller, executive director of the New Hampshire Association of Counties, opinion and practices vary among the 10 counties.
Burchell's motion carried by a margin of 10-to-8 as Fields, along with fellow Republicans Don Flanders and Bob Luther, both of Laconia, joined Huot and the other four Democrats — Ian Raymond of Sanbornton, Lisa DiMartino of Gilford, Beth Arsenault of Laconia and Ruth Gulick of New Hampton in the minority.
The convention then spent nearly three hours retracing the steps of its subcommittees, which met in marathon sessions last week, after Worsman apparently ordered them not to take formal votes on their recommendations. Those who flouted that directive, and those who followed it, reported their recommendations to the entire convention last night.
"Why are we voting without hearing from the public?" asked Gulick.
"This is a completely improper procedure," added Huot, who said that the convention should get information from the sub-committees, formulate a budget and present it to the public.
They were echoed by Fields who has questioned Worsman's conduct of the budget process from the outset. "I don't like this being rammed down our throats," he said, prompting Worsman to say "representative you are out of order."
"I may be out of order," Fields shot back , "but this is wrong." He told Worsman the convention would not be in this situation if she had asked the sub-committees not to make recommendations. "This has been a transition," Worsman replied.
"For you maybe," Fields remarked.
Rep. Herb Vadney (R-Meredith), who chaired one of the sub-committees, offered the motion to strike funds for a proposed three-percent step raise from the budget, along with funding for sick day and longevity bonuses. At the same time, he proposed requiring employees to pay the entire 7.3-percent increase in health insurance premiums, more than doubling their contribution.
Gulick asked why her sub-committee was told not to deal with salaries and benefits while apparently others were not.
"I either didn't hear or didn't listen," Vadney quipped.
The Democratic members of the convention questioned the wisdom of the measures, which they said would lead to higher rates of turnover among employees and a diminution in the quality of county services, especially the nursing home.
"I'm appalled" said Huot, who claimed the Republicans were "performing arthroscopic surgery with a meat axe."
Worsman took it upon herself to make the case for freezing wages and trimming benefits. "Every part of the economy is continuing to shrink," she said, stressing that public employees were receiving more generous raises and benefits than their counterparts in the private sector. ""This budget is $1.3-million too much and we must cut operating expenses," she said.
The motion to deny the pay raise was adopted on a straight party-line vote, 13 to five, but Fields joined the Democrats in seeking to spare employees the increase in health insurance premiums.
At 8 p.m. the public hearing, which was posted for 5 p.m., was opened to the pubic, who with few exceptions applauded the decisions of the convention, particularly the steps to control the growth of salaries. "Unions are not are friends," proclaimed one woman from Sanbornton, who added "the only check we have is you people. We don't have a union. If you fail us, you're not doing your duty."
Raymond was among several to remind the convention that the commissioners were in the midst of negotiating collective bargaining agreements with three unions representing county employees. He noted that the terms and conditions of the prior contract, including the bonuses for sick days and longevity as well as the employee's share of health insurance premiums, remain in effect until a new contract is reached.
Asked about the issue, Commissioner Ed Philpot (D-Laconia) said "we will not discuss contracts in a public meeting," but advised Worsman to top off the budget for legal expenses. Later she added $5,000.
Although the convention approved the recommendations of its sub-committees to reduce a number of expenditures, the size of the dent in the $26.8-million budget proposed by the commissioners remains to be calculated. Rep. Colette Worsman (R-Meredith), who chairs the convention, said that she aimed to cut $1.3-million from the budget, which would entirely offset the 8.9-percent increase in the county tax burden projected by the commissioners.
Shortly after Worsman opened the meeting, Rep. Richard Burchell (R-Gilmanton) proposed stripping the commission of much of its authority over the budget, in particular it power to transfer funds from line-to-line within the plan. Reading from a prepared statement, the freshman lawmaker, said that "the power of the purse belongs to you — the convention. The enumerated powers of commissions are very limited," he continued, charging that the commissioners "attempt to assign to themselves the powers granted to you."
Burchell cited state law (RSA 24:14) which reads "unless otherwise ordered by the county convention ... whenever it appears that the amount appropriated for a specific purpose will not be used in whole or in part for such purpose, the county commissioners may use such sum to augment other appropriations, if necessary, provided the total payments for all purposes do not exceed the total sum of appropriations in any year made by the county convention." The law, he insisted, is clear and the convention would be derelict in its duty to grant the commission discretion to transfer funds.
"The commission is not accountable" he declared, urging the convention "not to hide behind the veil of executive discretion."
For some years the commission has enjoyed authority to transfer funds, only seeking the approval of the executive committee for amounts of more than $10,000. Moreover, the convention's authority over the budget has been limited to the bottom-line, much as in towns where the budget committee and town meeting approve the total spending package while the board of selectmen retain the power to transfer funds between departments and line-items.
Rep. David Huot (D-Laconia) cautioned that by taking away the authority of the commission, the convention would make a lot of work for its executive committee, which could find itself managing the budget day-by-day.
Rep. Dennis Fields (R-Sanbornton) said he would votes against the motion because "I don't know what the legal ramifications are."
In fact, the delineation of budgetary authority between the convention and the commission is neither straightforward nor settled and according to Betsy Miller, executive director of the New Hampshire Association of Counties, opinion and practices vary among the 10 counties.
Burchell's motion carried by a margin of 10-to-8 as Fields, along with fellow Republicans Don Flanders and Bob Luther, both of Laconia, joined Huot and the other four Democrats — Ian Raymond of Sanbornton, Lisa DiMartino of Gilford, Beth Arsenault of Laconia and Ruth Gulick of New Hampton in the minority.
The convention then spent nearly three hours retracing the steps of its subcommittees, which met in marathon sessions last week, after Worsman apparently ordered them not to take formal votes on their recommendations. Those who flouted that directive, and those who followed it, reported their recommendations to the entire convention last night.
"Why are we voting without hearing from the public?" asked Gulick.
"This is a completely improper procedure," added Huot, who said that the convention should get information from the sub-committees, formulate a budget and present it to the public.
They were echoed by Fields who has questioned Worsman's conduct of the budget process from the outset. "I don't like this being rammed down our throats," he said, prompting Worsman to say "representative you are out of order."
"I may be out of order," Fields shot back , "but this is wrong." He told Worsman the convention would not be in this situation if she had asked the sub-committees not to make recommendations. "This has been a transition," Worsman replied.
"For you maybe," Fields remarked.
Rep. Herb Vadney (R-Meredith), who chaired one of the sub-committees, offered the motion to strike funds for a proposed three-percent step raise from the budget, along with funding for sick day and longevity bonuses. At the same time, he proposed requiring employees to pay the entire 7.3-percent increase in health insurance premiums, more than doubling their contribution.
Gulick asked why her sub-committee was told not to deal with salaries and benefits while apparently others were not.
"I either didn't hear or didn't listen," Vadney quipped.
The Democratic members of the convention questioned the wisdom of the measures, which they said would lead to higher rates of turnover among employees and a diminution in the quality of county services, especially the nursing home.
"I'm appalled" said Huot, who claimed the Republicans were "performing arthroscopic surgery with a meat axe."
Worsman took it upon herself to make the case for freezing wages and trimming benefits. "Every part of the economy is continuing to shrink," she said, stressing that public employees were receiving more generous raises and benefits than their counterparts in the private sector. ""This budget is $1.3-million too much and we must cut operating expenses," she said.
The motion to deny the pay raise was adopted on a straight party-line vote, 13 to five, but Fields joined the Democrats in seeking to spare employees the increase in health insurance premiums.
At 8 p.m. the public hearing, which was posted for 5 p.m., was opened to the pubic, who with few exceptions applauded the decisions of the convention, particularly the steps to control the growth of salaries. "Unions are not are friends," proclaimed one woman from Sanbornton, who added "the only check we have is you people. We don't have a union. If you fail us, you're not doing your duty."
Raymond was among several to remind the convention that the commissioners were in the midst of negotiating collective bargaining agreements with three unions representing county employees. He noted that the terms and conditions of the prior contract, including the bonuses for sick days and longevity as well as the employee's share of health insurance premiums, remain in effect until a new contract is reached.
Asked about the issue, Commissioner Ed Philpot (D-Laconia) said "we will not discuss contracts in a public meeting," but advised Worsman to top off the budget for legal expenses. Later she added $5,000.
Last Updated on Tuesday, 22 January 2013 22:45
Hits: 515
Gilford Police say road rage incident led 2 men to fight in middle of Lake Shore Road
GILFORD — A Belmont man and a Laconia man are each charged with disorderly conduct, reckless operation, and simple assault after allegedly getting into a fight during what police are calling a road rage incident.
According to Lt. James Leach, a patrol officer sitting in the Lowe's parking lot on Lake Shore Road just after midnight on Saturday saw two cars traveling side-by-side at a high rate of speed headed east or toward Alton.
He followed the two vehicles and saw them stopped in the middle of the road and two men, identified as Nicholas Briggs, 19, of 133 Middle Route in Belmont and Steven Diltz, 32, of 43 Addison St. in Laconia, fighting.
Briggs was driving a 2005 silver Chevy Equinox and Diltz was driving a 2003 yellow Ford Mustang.
Police said neither man was injured. Both were released on $1,000 personal recognizance bail and given a court date of February 21.
An additional Gilford Police officer and a N.H. State Trooper assisted with breaking up the fight and arresting the two men.
According to Lt. James Leach, a patrol officer sitting in the Lowe's parking lot on Lake Shore Road just after midnight on Saturday saw two cars traveling side-by-side at a high rate of speed headed east or toward Alton.
He followed the two vehicles and saw them stopped in the middle of the road and two men, identified as Nicholas Briggs, 19, of 133 Middle Route in Belmont and Steven Diltz, 32, of 43 Addison St. in Laconia, fighting.
Briggs was driving a 2005 silver Chevy Equinox and Diltz was driving a 2003 yellow Ford Mustang.
Police said neither man was injured. Both were released on $1,000 personal recognizance bail and given a court date of February 21.
An additional Gilford Police officer and a N.H. State Trooper assisted with breaking up the fight and arresting the two men.
Last Updated on Tuesday, 22 January 2013 04:19
Hits: 575
More Articles...
- Local pubs among those raising funds for David's House
- Local police chiefs say they're seeing big spike in applications for concealed gun permits
- Newfound recall's Ross's license plante, which spoke volumes about her
- State union asks Worsman for any records pertaining to GOP budget caucus
- Reps want county to pay legal bill for registrar of deeds; committee adds $5,200 to 2013 budget
- New Huot Center building is about half-way home